Differences Between Shingle and Metal Roofing

When the time comes to add a new roof to your home, you have many materials to choose from, including two of the most popular options: shingle and metal roofing. However, you might wonder which one of these options will best meet your needs. Discover the differences between shingle and metal roofing to determine which suits your home better.

Advantages of Shingle Roofing

Shingle roofing, which is often composed of asphalt, is one of the most prevalent roofing options available. This style of roof has many advantages, which we will delve into below.

It Is Cost Effective

One of the primary attractions of shingle roofing is its cost-effectiveness. Shingle roofing materials are generally more affordable than metal roofing options. This makes shingle roofing an ideal choice for homeowners on a budget or those looking to maximize their savings without compromising on quality.

It Lasts a Long Time

Another notable advantage of shingle roofing is its longevity. Some shingles have the ability to last up to 30 years on a roof.

Additionally, manufacturers build shingles to withstand weather, providing reliable protection against rain and snow for many years. This durability makes shingle roofing a dependable choice for people looking for protection for their homes.

Roofers Can Easily Install Shingles

If homeowners choose shingles for their roofs, they can also expect a relatively straightforward installation process. Manufacturers produce shingles that are easy to handle and require installers to use fewer tools and less specialized equipment than metal roofing.

This simplicity translates to faster installation times, potentially reducing labor costs and disruptions to homeowners. Moreover, the widespread availability of shingles and the familiarity most roofers have with this type of roofing material ensures that they will complete the installation efficiently and effectively. As a result, homeowners can enjoy a swift transition from an old or damaged roof to a brand-new one with an asphalt shingle roof installation.

Shingle Repairs Cost Less Than Metal Roof Repairs

Shingle repairs also are generally more affordable than those for metal roofs due to a combination of material costs and labor. Asphalt shingles are relatively inexpensive to purchase individually.

Additionally, repairing shingles requires less specialized knowledge and involves straightforward techniques that most professional roofers are well-versed in. This ease of repair and availability of materials results in reduced labor costs, ensuring homeowners can maintain their shingle roofs without incurring high expenses over the years.

Advantages of Metal Roofing

Metal roofing, which is typically made from materials such as steel, offers homeowners a modern and durable roofing solution. In this section, we will examine its longevity, energy efficiency, and other benefits.

Metal Roofs Last Even Longer

Metal roofs can also provide homes with longevity, outlasting their shingle counterparts by several decades. Due to their inherent strength and resilience, most metal roofing materials can last up to 75 years.

This also allows them to withstand severe weather conditions, including ice, hail, and snow. Moreover, metal roofs are resistant to rot, insect damage, and mildew, which can commonly affect other roofing types.

They Require Little Maintenance

Another key benefit of metal roofing is that they require little to no maintenance. Unlike shingle roofs, which may need periodic inspections and repairs to replace damaged or missing shingles, metal roofs are remarkably durable and resistant to common roofing issues.

Furthermore, modern metal roofing systems often feature protective coatings that prevent rust and corrosion, extending the roof's life. As a result, homeowners can enjoy more free time, reduced long-term maintenance costs, and the peace of mind that comes with a roof that requires little upkeep.

Metal Roofs Are Greener

Metal roofs can meet the needs of homeowners looking to reduce their carbon footprint. Because they often consist of recycled materials and are 100 percent recyclable at the end of their long lifespans, metal roofing significantly reduces waste compared to other roofing types.

Additionally, metal roofs enhance energy efficiency by reflecting solar radiant heat, which can lower your home’s cooling costs by up to 25 percent. This reflective property reduces energy consumption and contributes to a cooler, more comfortable indoor environment during hot weather.

Moreover, metal roofs' longevity and durability mean that homeowners must buy fewer replacements. This results in a less frequent use of resources, further benefiting the environment. Choosing a metal roof is an excellent way for environmentally conscious homeowners to embrace sustainability and energy efficiency.

They Are More Fire Resistant

Metal roofs can even give homeowners a sense of security in their residences. Although shingle roofs can provide some fire resistance, metal roofs are even stronger. They have a Class A fire rating, the highest rating possible, which means they are highly effective at withstanding fire exposure.

This makes them a particularly safe choice if you live in an area where wildfires tend to break out. This quality can also potentially lower insurance premiums, making metal roofing a secure and cost-effective option for homeowners.

Metal Roofs Offer More Aesthetic Options

One last benefit of metal roofs is that they provide a wider array of aesthetic options than shingle roofs, appealing to homeowners with diverse tastes and architectural styles.

Available in numerous colors, finishes, and designs, metal roofing can mimic the appearance of traditional materials, such as tile, slate, or wood shakes, while offering the added benefits of metal's durability and low maintenance. This versatility ensures metal roofing can complement various home styles, from contemporary to historic, making it a stylish choice for those looking to enhance their home's curb appeal.

How To Choose

After reviewing the differences between shingle and metal roofing, you may be closer to making a final decision for your home. Consider aspects such as your budget, climate, and aesthetic preferences.

Additionally, look at the installation and long-term maintenance costs and think about how energy-efficient you want your home to be. Consulting a professional roofer can also benefit you since they can provide tailored advice based on your home's specific needs and environmental conditions.

After reviewing these benefits, you can make a more informed choice for your roof. If you want to add shingle or metal roofing to your home, contact Schmucker Quality Construction LLC today. Our employees will work with you to install a roof that adds value to your home and provides the protection that you need.