top of page

Shingle Roofing vs. Metal Roofing: Which Is Right for You?

Updated: Feb 19

Selecting the appropriate roofing material is a critical decision that every homeowner must make. This choice significantly influences not just the durability and lifespan of a home’s roof but also the house’s aesthetic appeal and overall value. Therefore, investing time in understanding the different types of roofing materials available on the market is essential.

Two of the most common options for homeowners are shingles and metal roofing. Both materials offer specific benefits that can increase the function and appeal of your home. Read on to learn more about shingle and metal roofing materials to determine which is right for you.

The Basics of Shingle Roofing

Shingle roofing, a common choice among homeowners, is known for its versatility and affordability. Composed primarily of a base material, an adhesive binder, and granules, shingles function as an effective barrier against various weather conditions. The base material provides the structural integrity of the shingle, while the adhesive binder holds the granules in place. These granules, often made from ceramic-coated minerals, protect the shingle from harmful ultraviolet rays and enhance its fire resistance.

There are several types of shingle roofing to consider when planning your home’s roof. Asphalt shingles, the most popular choice, offer a balance between cost-effectiveness and durability. They consist of either an organic or fiberglass base saturated with asphalt and coated with mineral granules. Although more expensive, wood shingles add a natural and rustic charm to any home. They are typically made from cedar, pine, or redwood and require more maintenance than their asphalt counterparts.

Slate shingles, on the other hand, are known for their longevity and resilience. Made from natural stone, these shingles can last for decades if well-maintained, making them an excellent choice for those who prioritize durability. However, they are considerably more expensive and heavier than other types of shingles, requiring a stronger support structure. By understanding these different types of shingle roofing, homeowners can select the option that best fits their budget, aesthetic preference, and functional needs.

The Pros and Cons of Shingle Roofing

Shingle roofing brings several advantages that make it a popular choice among homeowners. One of the primary benefits of shingle roofing is its affordability. Compared to other roofing materials, shingles, particularly asphalt varieties, offer a more cost-effective solution without compromising durability or aesthetic appeal. Moreover, shingle roofs are relatively easy to install and repair, which can lead to lower labor costs.

Shingle roofing also offers a wide range of design options. With various colors, textures, and styles available, homeowners can customize their roofs to match their homes’ architectural styles. This versatility makes shingle roofing an excellent choice for those looking to enhance their home’s curb appeal.

However, shingle roofing comes with some drawbacks. While shingle roofs are durable, they may not last as long as other types of roofing, like metal or tile. On average, an asphalt shingle roof has a lifespan of 15–30 years, depending on the quality of installation and maintenance.

Another disadvantage of shingle roofing is its susceptibility to extreme weather conditions. High winds, heavy hail, and extreme heat can cause shingles to crack, warp, or even blow off. This vulnerability might require more frequent repairs or replacement, adding to the overall costs. For homeowners living in areas prone to severe weather conditions, these potential issues could be deal breakers when considering shingle roofing.

The Basics of Metal Roofing

Metal roofing stands as durable and long-lasting choice for many homeowners. Made from metal sheets, these roofs provide a sturdy barrier against the elements, with the metal panels interlocking to form a protective barrier that sheds water and resists high winds. The composition of a metal roof typically includes a metallic coating applied to steel or another metal to prevent rust. This coating is then painted to provide the desired color and to enhance the material’s resistance to the weather.

There are various types of metal used in roofing. Steel, one of the most commonly used metals, is known for its strength and durability. Often coated with zinc or a mixture of zinc and aluminum to prevent rusting, steel roofing can last for several decades with proper maintenance. Aluminum, another popular choice, is naturally corrosion-resistant, making it an excellent option for homes in coastal areas where salt water can cause corrosion to develop quickly. It is also lightweight, which makes it easier to install and puts less strain on the home’s structure.

Copper roofing, while not as common due to its higher cost, offers a unique aesthetic appeal with its natural patina that develops over time. Copper is also extremely durable and can last for years. However, it requires skilled installation to ensure it performs well, adding to its overall cost. Other popular metal roofing materials include galvalume, tin, weathering steel, corrugated metal, and more. Each of these metal roofing options has its own set of characteristics, allowing homeowners to choose what best fits their needs and budget.

The Pros and Cons of Metal Roofing

Metal roofing offers a range of advantages that can appeal to many homeowners. Among these benefits, the longevity of metal roofs stands out. Proper maintenance means a metal roof can last up to 70 years, which is significantly longer than traditional asphalt roofing. This durability makes metal roofing an excellent choice for homeowners who plan to stay in their homes for a long time and want a roof that requires minimal to no replacement.

Another advantage of metal roofing is its resistance to extreme weather conditions. Unlike other materials, metal does not crack or corrode, making it an ideal choice for homes in areas prone to harsh weather conditions, such as heavy rain, snow, or high winds. Metal roofs are also fire-resistant, adding an extra layer of safety for homes in areas prone to wildfires.

Despite these benefits, there are some disadvantages to consider with metal roofing. One major drawback is that metal roofs do not look like traditional shingle roofing units. If you prefer a more traditional-looking roof on your home, a modern metal roof style isn’t the ideal option for you. Additionally, metal roofs can be noisy during heavy rain or hail. While some people may not mind the sound, others might find it disruptive. Insulation can help reduce the noise, but it will add to the overall cost of installation. Finally, while metal roofs are generally durable, they can dent if hit by a heavy object, like a large hailstone or falling tree branch. Depending on the extent of the damage, these dents can be costly to repair.

Selecting the right roofing material for your home is a decision that should take into account several factors. These include your budget, the climate of your area, the architectural style of your home, and your personal aesthetic preferences. Both metal and shingle roofing have their own sets of advantages and disadvantages, but which is right for you?

If you are looking for a cost-effective and versatile option with a wide range of design choices, shingle roofing might be the right choice. On the other hand, if longevity, resistance to extreme weather conditions, and fire safety are your priorities, you might want to consider metal roofing.

At Schmucker Quality Construction, we offer both metal and shingle roof installation services. Our team of professionals is committed to providing top-quality work and customer service. We encourage you to explore our services further to see how we can meet your roofing needs. Whether you decide on a shingle or metal roof, we are here to ensure that you make the most informed decision and receive the highest quality installation services.

Shingle Roofing vs. Metal Roofing: Which Is Right for You?

107 views0 comments


bottom of page